This page contains a single entry from the blog posted on September 16, 2004 12:10 AM. The previous post in this blog was Busted. The next post in this blog is Cool down time. Many more can be found on the main index page or by looking through the archives.

E-mail, Feeds, 'n' Stuff

Thursday, September 16, 2004

Endangered species

It's been six years since we closed on our current home, where the Irvington and Alameda neighborhoods meet in Northeast Portland. And in that time, the neighborhood grocery store has virtually disappeared from sight.

Upon our arrival here, we had not one but two smaller groceries less than three blocks away, both at the corner of NE 24th and Fremont -- Nature's, a whole-food, bulk-product, low-packaging, earth-friendly market which at two storefronts wide was still pretty small; and Alameda Foods, a more traditional small grocery with all the plastic corporate American fare you could ever want. Both had fresh meat, a deli, and produce galore. The lines were short, and the convenience was incredible. If we needed a lemon, some maple syrup, a loaf of bread, or a bottle of wine, it was an easy walk and a quick errand. There was no thought of taking the car. The fresh air was good for the soul.

But it started to slide downhill soon after we arrived. Nature's packed up and headed nine blocks west to expanded quarters at NE 15th and Fremont. It was great for the new neighborhood, but not so hot at the old location. In its place there, after a substantial vacancy period, came a restaurant and a high-priced garden store. They both folded after very brief runs. Since then, another restaurant has come and gone, and a second garden store -- not as ritzy, but still not at all down-to-earth -- is hanging in there on the site.

Meanwhile, Nature's was bought out by Wild Oats from Colorado, and a new Portland-based chain, New Seasons, has sprung up elsewhere in Northeast, giving the new owners of Nature's a serious run for their money. Wild Oats has lost its pharmacy, much of its clientele, and whatever charm it may have had to go with its quirky attitude. It's not a very fun place to shop, and the help never smiles any more, either.

Across 24th from the old Nature's site, Alameda Foods reportedly had its rent abruptly jacked up, and the Arab-American guys who ran the place folded it. Now we have a commercial bank branch, which I can't believe anyone from the neighborhood ever patronizes, and a long-empty storefront that's apparently going to be a dentist's office. How cold is that?

From a comestible standpoint, then, what have we got left? A 10-block sojourn to the nearest fresh food place, and a somewhat forlorn scene when you get there. Except in periods of major ambition, the car is involved. And if you're in the car, why not drive 25 blocks to the New Seasons in the Concordia neighborhood, where the shopping is so much better?

All this is old news, I guess, but now the same thing is happening in the heart of Irvington, at NE 15th and Brazee. What had been a funky little food market for as long as I've lived in Portland, has recently been vacated and gutted to make way for what the landlord hopes will be a toney Italian restaurant and some sort of pricey clothing store. And so people down that way will be forced to deal with Safeway, Fred Meyer, Wild Oats or the new Zupan's (in the ghastly new condo tower on NE Broadway) whenever they need something as simple as a tomato. The old Irvington Market on NE Weidler is gone too, of course, displaced by a fast-food Chinese cafeteria that would be just perfectly appropriate for a bad shopping mall in Detroit.

How very sad.

A pox on all the landlords, I say. Fie on the toney new restaurants. Fie on the garden stores with the platinum-plated hoes and spades. Fie on the dentist's office where the Romaine lettuce is supposed to be. I won't patronize them until there's a little grocery store back in the neighborhood.

The livable city gets a little less livable every time an independent grocer is forced to close up shop. I really wish the Big Idea People down at City Hall would try to do something to preserve these small businesses, instead of embarking on all the misguided mischief that the bureaucrats are so good at. Instead they kiss up to Home Depot, who will run out all the mom-and-pop hardware stores, too.

Comments (9)

A fie and a pox? Dude, that's cold-blooded.

Not to be too critical but all of your lamentations smack of, "Back when I was a kid..." or "Things were so much better back then..." Of course, it could all be true, but to me it sounds more like a person unwilling to live with change and who desires to have things just the way they want it.

My daughter cries whenever she passes by the store at 15th and Brazee, which we called Kim's (long story, old family history involved.)

It was very near our old house and on the way to her old school, so it turned into a special place to stop in for candy or a treat of sorts.

However - everyone knew never, ever, ever to buy meat in there. And the produce was way sad as well. Alas, it fell victim to the downward spiral of shopping habits - if people don't buy it, they won't stock it, and so on...

I miss the theoretical value of having a close neighborhood store to drop in for that quick run for milk - but I'd not have bought a tomato there. Or much else other than milk, butter, candy or the occasional beer.

Sadly, the fault for the demise of neighborhood stores lies as much with their patrons and store owners/managers as it does the big conglomerates and landlords.

Or, in other words - if that store had been better stocked/run, it might still be around...

And the Californication continues...

Remember your local dairy?

I understand that Mayor Katz gave New Seasons some important help with the new store they are building in North Portland. You got your wish and you didn't even know it.

Progress stinks, doesn't it? The reason the big stores do well is because they can provide lower prices and greater selection. And when people pay lower prices for their food, they have more money to spend on other things. That's supposed to be good, not bad.

And let me get this straight, you don't want the city intervening in the private market to encourage redevelopment of a dumpy portion of Northwest Portland into the Pearl District, but you DO want the city to intervene to subsidize mom and pop grocery stores in Northeast Portland, instead of going ten blocks to a store with greater selection and lower prices?

I am sad to hear the 15th and Brazee market has bitten the dust. That was my neighborhood market when I lived at 21st and Hancock, about 3 years ago. And I have to agree that that is/was part of the charm of Portland: a city that still felt like a series of tight neighborhoods.
And what you're describing is part of the reason we moved to Butte, Montana. Portland just got too big and busy, too much like Seattle. I lived there for 10 years and loved it, and will always remember '90s Portland fondly.

gotta chime in. i do wish there were other shopping venues for my neighborhood. i'm in overlook and we have nothing right now, but Safeway on MLK which is still the dirtiest store around. Freddy's is re-building on lombard, but then again, that's no longer NW supported. New Seasons? Yeh! That is NW supporting and they are going to do community redevelopment.

I agree with the above post about the demise of the small shops also lays on the hands of the shoppers - Jack - when you chose to shop @ Walmart or Costco because they are cheaper, that is taking the money out of the hands of the small businessman - all of them, not just the grocer.

Put your money where your mouth is.

Clicky Web Analytics